Multisite Churches

Do Megachurches Provide a Better Religious Experience than Smaller Churches?

By October 3, 2018 No Comments

Leadership Network’s work with innovative pastors regularly pairs us with megachurches. Indeed, in recent years no one has done more megachurch research than us.Thought leader @lensweet recently tweeted “No one knows more about the megachurch than @warrenbird.” (By definition, megachurches are Protestant congregations that draw 2,000 or more to weekly worship.)

We are also quick to affirm the importance and strategic role of smaller churches. Many are pacesetters in evangelism, missional connections and compassion ministries. We and other researchers have much to learn from them.

But what about megachurch researchers who are not connected with Leadership Network? Do their findings square with Leadership Network’s megachurch biases? In a recent “mystery church shopper” report, megachurches fared quite well. Hard research is likewise affirming. National studies like FACT,  USCLS and NCS touch on megachurches, but two others drew enough large church participants to reach significant conclusions:

1. Rodney Stark of Baylor University compared churches with attendances under 100 against those over 1,000, reporting it in What Americans Really Believe. He sought to determine whether large or small congregations provide a better religious experience – see the two infographics which highlight a number of his findings. He concludes that the “mile wide and inch deep” accusations of megachurches, taken as a whole, lack a research base.

2. Barna Research wrote How Faith Varies by Church Size.” Its study found attenders of large churches were more likely than those engaged in a small or mid-sized congregation to give an orthodox biblical response – such as that Jesus led a sinless life, the Bible is totally accurate in all the principles it teaches, Satan is not merely symbolic but exists, God is the all-powerful creator of the world who still rules the universe, etc. Further, on seven of the eight behavioral measures, attenders of large churches scored substantially better than those of small churches. Activities included attending church in the past week, reading the Bible in the past week, and volunteering at their church in the past week. The average difference related to the seven behaviors was 17 percentage points.

 

what's next bookDave Travis, co-author of Megachurch Myths and CEO of Leadership Network, is not surprised by these findings. “Large churches and small churches are both valid expressions of Christian discipleship. But the fiercest critics of larger churches poke at them without data from those that actually attend them. Most of the data cited in this blog tends to show how literally millions of Americans find large church expressions of church life vital, renewing and life giving for their spiritual journeys,” he says. For more from Dave Travis on larger churches, see also What’s Next? A Look Over the Next Hill for Innovative Churches and Their Leaders.

For other installments in this “megachurch” series see www.leadnet.org/megachurch and www.leadnet.org/world.

 

Related Posts

Warren Bird

Author Warren Bird

Warren Bird, Ph.D. has been named a Leadership Network Senior Fellow in light of his exemplary service 2006-2018 as Director of Research and Intellectual Capital Development at Leadership Network. He serves as full-time VP of Research for ECFA.org (Evangelical Council for Financial Accountability). An ordained minister with background as both a pastor and seminary professor, Warren is an award-winning author or co-author of 31 books for ministry leaders including Hero Maker with Dave Ferguson, How to Break Church Growth Barriers with Carl George, and Next: Pastoral Succession that Works with William Vanderbloemen. Other recent titles are Better Together: Making Church Mergers Work with Jim Tomberlin, and Wisdom from Lyle E. Schaller. Some of Warren’s recent online reports include "Leadership Network/Generis Multisite Church Scorecard," and "The Heartbeat of Rising Influence Churches." See also research reports at leadnet.org/megachurchleadnet.org/salary and leadnet.org/portable. He is widely recognized as one of the nation's leading researchers of megachurches, multisite churches, large church compensation and high-visibility pastoral succession. He also oversees the world's only active, sortable list of global megachurches. Follow him on Twitter @warrenbird.  Click here to subscribe to Leadership Network Advance to get updates from Leadership Network.

More posts by Warren Bird

Your spot has been saved!

You will receive an e-mail shortly with more details about the webinar. Please watch your inbox.

X